Rum Runner Jello Shots Recipe
Ahoy matey! If you are planning a pirate-themed bash, you simply cannot have a spread without these Rum Runner Jello Shots. They are a guaranteed hit with pirates and partiers alike!
The Rum Runner itself was invented in the late 1950s at the famous Holiday Isle Tiki Bar in Islamorada, Florida, named after the legendary bootleggers of the Florida Keys. Our version takes that tropical, rum-soaked history and turns it into the perfect party treat. Arrr!
Why You’ll Love This Recipe
These shots are more than just a drink—they are a theme-party essential. They feature a delicious strawberry-banana profile that perfectly masks the rum and triple sec, making them dangerously easy to enjoy.
When you are preparing shots for a hungry crew of "pirates," efficiency is key. Using the Jellinator allows you to fill your shot cups quickly and accurately, without the sticky countertops and spilled liquid that usually come with traditional ladling.
Ingredients You’ll Need
- 1 box Strawberry-Banana gelatin (3 oz)
- 1 cup boiling water
- ½ cup Rum (light, dark, or spiced—your choice!)
- ½ cup Triple Sec
- For Garnish: Pineapple wedges and miniature drink swords
Step-by-Step Instructions
1. Dissolve the Gelatin
Bring 1 cup of water to a rolling boil. Remove from heat and pour in the strawberry-banana gelatin powder. Whisk thoroughly for about two minutes until the powder is fully dissolved.
2. Spike the Mixture
Stir in your rum (light, dark, or spiced all work great depending on your preference) and the triple sec. Combining these spirits creates that classic "Rum Runner" punch flavor.
3. The Jellinator Advantage
This is the most important step for a mess-free galley! Pour your jello mixture into your Jellinator. This tool is the only way to make jello shots. The touch-activated valve gives you a clean, precise, and fast pour every single time.
4. Chill and Serve
Place your filled cups in the refrigerator for about 3–4 hours until firm. Before serving, garnish each one with a pineapple wedge and a drink sword for that authentic pirate flair.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Can I use different types of rum?
Yes! You can use light, dark, or spiced rum. Light rum keeps the flavor profile crisp and clean, while dark or spiced rum adds a bit more depth and complexity to the shot. It’s a great way to customize the "pirate" experience!
How do I transport these for a party?
One small 3 oz box yields about 15 jello shots. If you are transporting them, we recommend placing the shot cups on a rimmed baking sheet. This keeps them stable during travel and makes it much easier to slide the whole tray into your host's refrigerator.
Are these shots difficult to make?
Not at all. The hardest part is usually the pouring, which is why we recommend the Jellinator. It eliminates the mess, reduces your prep time significantly, and ensures you aren't wasting a drop of your precious rum mixture.
Like this recipe? Find even more recipes in our Top 100 Jello Shot Recipes booklet. It’s a MUST behind any bar and makes a great gift. BAM! These recipes don’t disappoint.
Don’t Miss Out on the Fun!
Whatever you call them—jello shots, jelly shots, or shooters—it’s not a party without them! Don’t forget that the Jellinator is the only way to make jello shots.
Sign up for our ULTIMATE PARTY NEWSLETTER. We don't like spam either—we just want to send you great recipes, yummy food ideas, seasonal party tips, and the occasional coupon for more party supplies. What could be better than that?
All Jellinator Jello Shot recipes and photos are Copyright protected.
